Skip to Content

Is It Ever a Good Idea to Let Your Tenant Sublet?

A female subletting tenant carrying boxes with personal belongings.Owning rental property often means dedicating significant effort to identify the ideal tenants. Tenants might sometimes sublease their place to save money, with or without the landlord’s approval. This scenario commonly unfolds for tenants who have entered into long-term leases but will be away from their property for a long time. Preferring not to dissolve the lease, tenants could find subletting to be a superior option. This document will facilitate your understanding of this matter and assist in finding an agreeable solution for everyone.

The term subletting denotes when a tenant leases out a section of their dwelling, such as a bedroom, and remains living there. This method might seem advantageous for tenants aiming to make some extra cash, yet it frequently alarms landlords. As someone who owns property, it’s crucial to balance the merits and demerits of allowing subletting. We shall now scrutinize some of these elements in detail.

Who is Responsible?

There are two primary ways in which subletting happens. In the first scenario, a legal sublet, the landlord authorizes the tenant to lease out either the entire property or a portion of it to another tenant. Alternatively, an illegal sublet happens when the tenant subleases the property to another without the landlord’s consent.

In matters of subletting, the original tenant carries the legal duty to comply with their lease and guarantee the complete rent payment. Hence, the original tenant retains the ultimate responsibility, even in scenarios where subletting is sanctioned. Smooth operations notwithstanding, subletting demands substantial trust in the original tenant to ensure the subtenant complies with the lease terms.

Reasons Not to Allow Subletting

As the landlord or property manager, the choice to authorize subletting rests solely with you. Nonetheless, keep in mind that in some instances, subletting could be limited by homeowners’ associations or various regulations. If such agreements preclude subletting, this may serve as the only justification for you to restrict your tenant from subletting the space.

Additionally, the risk of not being able to collect rent from a subtenant—who stops making payments while the original tenant is away—might dissuade you from allowing subletting. This would necessitate locating your original tenant to obtain the rent, an endeavor that might be both arduous and time-consuming. Should the sublet prove to be illegal, accepting rent from a subtenant is crucially something to avoid. Accepting payments from a subtenant, even under illegal conditions, might confer rights to them on the property, requiring eviction to end such claims.

Reasons to Allow Subletting

A number of property owners authorize subletting as a strategy to maintain occupancy. This applies mainly if a tenant anticipates being away for a lengthy period. Keeping a healthy relationship with your tenant is vital, and enabling them to arrange what best fits their needs is an effective approach. By permitting your tenant to sublet, you also minimize the risk of vacancies and the associated turnover expenses, provided that the rent is consistently paid on time.

Subletting Agreements

It’s highly recommended to establish a detailed subletting agreement that specifies your expectations and the duties of your tenant. Even if you’re indifferent to subletting, having a section in your lease that clearly describes permitted actions and their applicable times is vital. With open and clear communication, misunderstandings can be bypassed, ensuring a harmonious and tension-free rental experience for both landlord and tenant.

If you’re leaning towards allowing subletting, it’s vital to take crucial precautions to ensure your and your property’s safety. Screening the subletting tenant thoroughly, as you would do for any prospective tenant, should be among the initial steps taken. Having selected a fitting tenant, it becomes crucial to define explicit expectations and regulations for the subletting deal. The process entails devising and endorsing a sublease agreement that encapsulates the entire terms and conditions governing the subletting setup. The establishment of a sublease agreement can act as a safeguard against any potential disputes or complications that could arise later on.

Seeking clarity on enabling your tenant to sublease your rental space? No worries, Real Property Management Keystone has got you covered! Contact us online or call 412-385-2300 to talk to a rental property expert today. Our team of pros is here to help you make the best decision for your property in Dormont or nearby.

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. See Equal Housing Opportunity Statement for more information.

The Neighborly Done Right Promise

The Neighborly Done Right Promise ® delivered by Real Property Management, a proud Neighborly company

When it comes to finding the right property manager for your investment property, you want to know that they stand behind their work and get the job done right – the first time. At Real Property Management we have the expertise, technology, and systems to manage your property the right way. We work hard to optimize your return on investment while preserving your asset and giving you peace of mind. Our highly trained and skilled team works hard so you can be sure your property's management will be Done Right.

Canada excluded. Services performed by independently owned and operated franchises.

See Full Details